Back ] Up ] Next ]
Past Work
Silicon Info


Silicon Info: Minority-Charge Carrier Lifetime, t

If some of a Si solar cell's generated carriers recombine at defects, impurities, surface damage, etc. before reaching the contacts, the current output is diminished.  Because it is a quantitative measure of such phenomena, minority-carrier lifetime (
t) characterization (ASTM, 1993) is frequently used to qualify the crystalline Si material before it is used in device processing. Quality in a silicon PV material is nearly synonymous with t. The parameters used in crystal growth have a direct bearing on t, because they determine impurity levels and defect structures that give rise to carrier recombination sites. Impurity incorporation, segregation, and evaporation during the crystal-growth process can be altered via ambient choice, growth rate, number of solidification steps, choice of container, heat-source characteristics, selection of source material, and other factors that vary from one process to another.

Heavy doping imposes an upper limit on lifetime according to tA = 1/CANA2, where tA is the Auger-limit lifetime.  CA is the Auger coefficient, and Nt < 2 ms is unlikely to be useful in most PV processes due to balance-of-systems costs. Poor-quality material cannot generate enough PV energy to justify the costs of the total PV system.  Thus, the t-N space available for PV applications is the non-hatched region in the figure below-left, and the four labeled curves are "quality" contours.  In addition to the two limits, curves representing moderate t (typical of Czochralski-grown CZ silicon) and high t (typical of the best commercially available FZ silicon) are included.  Note that there is a vast discrepancy between tA and the lifetime of the best available silicon. So there is potential for higher lifetimes and new device designs to take advantage of it.  Transition-metal impurity effects on t and solar cell efficiency as a function of their concentration levels are reasonably well understood from quantitative and detailed experimental studies (Davis et al., 1980).  Some metals such as titanium have a significant effect on t even in concentrations as low as a few 100 ppta (parts per trillion, atomic).  Others, such as copper, can be tolerated at a few ppma (parts per million, atomic).  Fortunately, most of the detrimental impurities have small effective segregation coefficients, and their concentrations can be reduced during directional solidification (DS).

When no impurities are present in high enough concentration to affect t, a myriad of structural defects can still act as recombination centers.  Grain boundaries and their associated dislocation arrays usually constrain t to <20 ms.  The lifetime of Si decreases with decreasing grain area as reported by Ciszek et al. (1993) and illustrated below-right.  Even dispersed dislocations in a single crystal at a density < 5x104cm-2 can reduce t to 30 ms in material that, when grown in the same way except dislocation-free, yields t = 450 ms.  If grain boundaries, dispersed dislocations, and transition-metal impurities are present, as may be the case in ingots cast from low-grade silicon feedstock, it is not unusual to see t <10 ms. 

Si crystals that are free of transition-metal impurities, dislocations, and grain boundaries unveil second-order structural effects on lifetime.  These are most easily seen in FZ material because O and C effects somewhat obscure the issue in CZ crystals.  Types A and B swirl micro defects (Si interstitial cluster defects) are present in dislocation-free FZ crystals that are grown at a speed v that is too slow or in a temperature gradient G that is too large.   Eliminating these defects allows t > 1 ms. When A and B swirls are eliminated, a third-order effect is unveiled - t varies inversely with cooling rate, the product of vxG, in swirl-free crystals.  Thus, v should be just fast enough to eliminate swirls if very high lifetimes are required.  The physical nature of this "fast cooling" defect is not understood at the present time. By appropriate choice of v and G, Ciszek et al. (1989) obtained t > 20 ms in lightly doped, p-type, high-purity silicon and were able to grow crystals on a quality contour an order of magnitude better than the one labeled "high" in the figure.

   t-N space for photovoltaic applications 

Effect of Grain Size on t

ASTM (1993) F28-91 Standard. 1993 Annual Book of ASTM Standards, Vol. 10.05, Philadelphia, American Society for Testing and Materials, 30.
Ciszek, T.F., Wang, T.H., Burrows, R.W., Wu, X., Alleman, J., Tsuo, Y.S., and Bekkedahl, T. (1993) 23th IEEE Photovoltaic Specialists Conf. Record, Louisville (IEEE, New York), 101.
Ciszek, T.F., Wang, Tihu, Schuyler, T., and Rohatgi, A. (1989) J. Electrochem. Soc. 136, 230.
Davis, J.R., Jr., Rohatgi, A., Hopkins, R.H., Blais, P.D., Rai-Choudhury, P., McCormick, J.R., and Mollenkopf, H.C. (1980) IEEE Trans. Electron. Devices ED-27, 677.


Siliconsultant, P.O. Box 1453, Evergreen, CO 80437 USA                         



This page was last updated on June 19, 2016